mellowtigger: (tech support)
[personal profile] mellowtigger
What do you know about Network Attached Storage (NAS)? I have a specific set of features that I want, and I'm wondering how best (and frugally) to achieve it.  It seemed too complex a technical question to type in a tweet or other social media, so I'm writing it up here.

The end-purpose of this storage device will be simply to save many files that are quite large but seldom accessed: games, movies, and eventually security cam archives.  Speaking of games, I expect Star Citizen to need 150GB when it finally releases, but that's another post.

The features that I want are these:
  1. Varieties of hard drive capacities, because I want to reuse the old hard drives I already have laying around without having to buy a fleet ($$$) of the same drive models whenever I want more capacity.
  2. SATA 3.5" hard drives, because the old drives I have are that physical size and interface.
  3. Redundancy, so any one hard drive can fail without losing data.
  4. Low power usage, so I can keep it online fulltime without expecting to see my electric bill spike upwards ($$$).
  5. Ethernet accessible, so any number of devices in the house could use it simultaneously.
I don't care if it requires technical tinkering to get it to work.  I don't care (for now) if it offers a powershell interface.  I don't care (for now) if it offers HDMI 4K output for streaming movies to television.  I don't need cloud backup or redundant power supply.  So that brings me to the main question:

What do I select for hardware and software?

Software: I never remember RAID levels without looking them up every time I discuss them, but I'm wondering if Feature #1 above means that I should actually be looking at unRAID as my software choice.  It also serves Feature #4 well.  And it's cheap, since it's also free ($$$) for only 3 drives total (1 stripe + 2 data).  So, I've already halfway convinced myself to give it a try, unless someone points me to a more common alternative that works well.

Hardware: Which leaves the hardware choice entirely up to me.  Buy some traditional NAS then just overwrite its operating system?  Buy a regular desktop computer system, but overwrite it then fill it with as many hard drives as it can handle?  Is there a cheap rack solution that might even allow hot-pluggable SATA drives?  Too many options, so I don't even know where to start.

I'm open to brainstormed ideas and real-world anecdotes.

Date: 2017-08-28 03:22 am (UTC)
foeclan: (Default)
From: [personal profile] foeclan
You say you want to re-use your existing hard drives. What's the capacity, SATA speed, and rotation speed of the drives?

If you want to run games off of a NAS, you need to consider your network infrastructure. Gigabit Ethernet is going to be slower than SATA, so you're likely to have latency issues that might make the game unplayable.

Profile

mellowtigger: (Default)
mellowtigger

September 2017

S M T W T F S
     12
3456789
10111213141516
1718192021 2223
24252627282930

Most Popular Tags

Page Summary

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Sep. 23rd, 2017 01:46 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios